|
yping88 发表于 16-6-2013 20:34
Hey, how's your weekend been so far?
I have been doing a lot of thinking recently about somethin ...
Thanks yping88 for bringing up this controversial topic, and her kind invitation.
I have found it a tricky and comprehensive question since it involves emotions, death, longevity, public decision, medicare, potential medical levy increment… (am I going too far?), and it will generally lead to hot debates.
By reading through the comments, I feel it would be wise to stay conservative on such topics in order not to irritate anybody.
But if I am living just to please others, that's not me.
Be silent, or speak up!
My point of view could not be simpler. "Try our best to save people's lives,
regardless of his own will."
If a person wants to commit suicide, prevent him.
If a person is mentally incompetent, and his guardian wants him to die, prevent him.
It has nothing to do with religion, or morality. It is just to respect the very nature of human being, to live.
When it comes to the real world, we still have to determine what is "best".
Please note that I didn't use the expression of "spare no efforts".
Think about the following scenarios,
To extend an individual's life for two years, spend trillions of dollars that could have been used to help thousands of refugees out of starvation?
To save an individual's life, take the risk of exposing hundreds of people to a fatal disease?
I bet most of us would say no.
Why? The real world is full of compromise.
Law is made by compromise, convention is also a compromise, and this topic is yet another compromise. It does not make sense to maximise one's interest by sacrificing the others, so the "best" here means the most efforts one can make with a bearable cost.
Then, getting back to this particular case, we can find that it is more of an economic question than a moral question, without the restriction of law and convention.
As long as the current action remains economic, there is no need to change. But when the time that it breaks the economical balance point comes, it is beyond our reach.
Hope my taking this radical stance will not hurt anyone. It may be right, and may not. Nobody is the judge, but time will tell.
|
评分
-
查看全部评分
|