阅读和听力同时进行反而不如单独练习听力提高的快？

monster2006

When learning a second language, students are taught to read, write, and listen often simultaneously, as it is assumed that it is more effective if both spoken and written versions of the same material are taught together. However, recent research on cognitive load theory and second language learning (Diao, Chandler, & Sweller, 2007; Diao & Sweller, 2007) has shown that a combination of listening to and reading the same material creates a potential for redundancy (Sweller & Chandler, 1994; Kalyuga, Chandler, & Sweller, 1999; 2000; 2004). Learning can be impeded if the same information appearing in one modality is repeated in the other (Sweller, 2005). The aim of this study was to investigate the consequences of listening and reading on the acquisition of listening skills. Four experiments were conducted. During acquisition, native Arabic-speaking students were required to learn a set of English words and sentences. Learners were either exposed to written work only (single modality), auditory work only (single modality) or written work with an auditory component (dual modality). The findings in this study were consistent in that even though participants in the Read + Listen group had had more experience with listening than participants in the Read Only group, they performed more poorly on listening tasks. Students were better able to learn to listen through reading alone because working memory resources were not required to attend to another mode that contained similar, redundant information. These results also suggest that if we want learners to enhance their listening skills, they may be better off reading the materials only rather than simultaneously reading and listening. These results are further discussed in terms of CLT and redundancy.

以前一直喜欢看电影时开着英文字幕来着，看来反而会妨碍学习啊，不如直接听提高得快
听过直接模仿学习还是最自然的方式，我想

不知道大家怎么看？

得分后卫

觉得先听一段，再看段字幕看那些听不懂的地方，感觉不全是听力的问题，更多的是常用口语/俚语不知道，所以听不出来。