兄弟恋 Starcrossed

xblues

Starcrossed (2005)

同性兄弟之间的恋情，这样一个绝对禁忌，绝少被人碰触的题材，居然被拍成了一部电影，虽然只有短短的15分钟，我还是比较吃惊。本片片长一共只有15分钟，主演是两个可爱的男孩，而故事情节则采用普通100分钟片场电影的方式平铺直叙，因此剧情比较简单自然，也没有对感情发展细节的刻画，尽管是一个完整的故事，但是从伦理的角度上并没有给观众更多的启发与思考空间。

给观众一种涉足禁忌，偷吃禁果的刺激感，但同时又不想受到传统道德伦理与舆论的谴责，这样双赢而成功的例子并不少见。比如说我们所熟知的日本电视连续剧『血疑』，导演最后不得不把剧本搞成非亲生兄妹的恋情，应该是考虑大众的承受能力。同样中国的『梁祝』，明明是同性的恋情，却要把其中一个写成原来是女扮男装，也应该是考虑主流大众的接受程度而不得不做的改变。由俄国的名著『洛丽塔』改编的电影，描写的则是继父对继女的恋情也属于这类。更有『航运新闻』，描写的是移居美国多年的母亲和儿子回到偏远的北欧寻亲，原来新生儿子是母亲被其兄长强暴而生的。最近看的一部涉及乱伦的电影应该是『Savage Grace』了，据说这部电影是根据40年代一个轰动了英国的儿子杀死母亲的案件改编的，剧本本身并没有对母子恋情做什么调整，但是最终还是以悲剧收场。我是觉得为了充分去迎合大众的猎奇心理，又要做到全身而退，本来就离奇的恋情，却还要强加上道德的注脚是何等的伪善呢。

当然本片没有把这对兄弟解释成原来是非亲生的，也没有把其中一个异性化，立意上还是比较诚实的。鲁迅先生说过悲剧是把美好的东西撕碎了给别人看，本片也同样安排了一个悲剧的结局。我是觉得没有必要把自己不认同或者不能够忍受的观点强加于别人，每一种情感都有它存在的理由，赞同的就给予支持，不赞同的大可以耸耸肩，说无所所谓。

                               
登录/注册后可看大图

http://www.56.com/n_v157_/c36_/27_/25_/htt4210498_/zhajm_120551913620_/915000_/0_/30793304.swf

chubbycat

The boy said to his brother: I don't want to be he (referring to his father)  wanted me to be

xblues

The boy also said I want to be you (to his brother).

Although I am the older son, and I dont have a brother like his, but I kinda understand his feeling. It's like after been defeated so many times, he sort of give up, and turn to his brother, his brother is like his hero figure (It really should have been his father).

I think the way their parent handled this was extremely impropriety. It might be just a phase, eventually they may find someone else in love. However, for me, I don't see how wrong this can possibly be. It's okay, they love each other, they didn't harm anyone. Let them go.

chubbycat

very sad story

xblues

×Hugs×, Maomao don't cry...